The law relating to withholding tax in Oman was amended in February 2017, extending its applicability to specific categories of income realised in Oman, as explained in an article in the June 2017 edition of the Client Alert (Oman Introduces Withholding Tax for Foreign Investors).
Following the introduction of the new tax law, the tax authorities published a clarification on their website to the effect that withholding tax on services would apply only to services wholly or partly rendered in Oman, and not to services fully rendered from outside Oman.
In March 2018, however, the Oman tax authorities issued a further clarification modifying the original position. The latest clarification stipulates that withholding tax will now apply to income realised in Oman by foreign persons for the provision of services irrespective of where those services were performed.
Accordingly, payments to foreign service providers will be subject to tax deduction at a rate of 10% of the gross amounts due, wherever the services were rendered.
Potential taxpayers should check Oman’s tax treaty network to determine if a more favourable withholding tax position can be adopted. They are also advised to seek appropriate professional advice on the applicability of the withholding tax.
Monday, May 14, 2018
Witholding Tax Update
Monday, May 7, 2018
Drafting Arbitration Clauses - Part III: Choice of Laws and Procedural Rules
Introduction
When entering into a contract and drafting an arbitration clause there are a number of choice of law issues that parties must consider. Parties commonly include a clause that sets out the substantive law of the agreement, known as the governing law clause. Often the governing law of the contract is not the same law as where the contract is performed or where an arbitration takes place (the seat of the arbitration). This article will outline a number of key considerations related to the selection of law and procedural rules that should be taken into account when entering into a contract.
Governing law
The governing law refers to the applicable law governing the contract. This is the main choice of law; it will govern the contract and be the law governing the substantive merits of any dispute arising from the contract. Commonly, parties will select a governing law that does not have any connection with the dispute or the parties entering into the contract. For example, parties entering into cross-border contracts frequently select the law of England and Wales as the law governing the contract as the law of England and Wales is perceived as a certain, stable law with reputable and independent courts.
It should also be mentioned that it is not common for parties to agree to a separate choice of law to apply to an arbitration clause which is different from the governing law of the contract. Having a law the governs the arbitration clause that is separate from the main contact is inadvisable as it would only add an unnecessary layer of complexity to an agreement.
Law of seat of the arbitration
The seat of the arbitration is the physical place, or in other words juridical place, of the arbitration. Often the law of the seat is different from the governing law of the contract. This is noteworthy in a number of respects. First, the law governing the seat of the arbitration will be the procedural law governing the arbitration. Second, the award will be rendered at the seat of the arbitration and therefore the award will have to comply with legal requirements of that jurisdiction. Third and most importantly, if the award needs to be enforced in a foreign country, the country of the seat of the arbitration should be a signatory to the New York Convention (or other applicable convention) to ensure that it can be enforced. Therefore it is critical that the seat of the arbitration is located in a country that is signatory to the New York Convention to ensure that a potential award can be enforced in a multitude of foreign countries.
Applicable arbitral rules (forum selection)
The applicable arbitration rules are the set of rules that will govern the dispute and the forum in which the dispute resolution procedure will take place. While this is not a choice of law per say, it is extremely important to select an appropriate set of arbitration rules. Typically parties select an institution to administer an arbitration, and each institution will apply its set of rules to the dispute. Therefore, when selecting an institution, parties must be clear as to the forum that they are selecting. In terms of the relationship between any applicable law and applicable rules, the applicable law will take precedence over any conflict with the rules; however, it is unlikely that a conflict between the law and rules will arise.
Practical drafting considerations
Most of the time when parties choose multiple laws in a contract, for example, a substantive law that differs from the law of the seat, there are no conflict of law issues that arise. When problems do arise that relate to the selection of applicable laws and procedural rules, this occurs because the choices are not clear or contain errors. One common error is when parties select the “law of the United Kingdom” to govern their agreement: there are in fact four separate systems of law in the United Kingdom. Another common problem is parties naming the rules of a non-existent arbitration center to govern the procedure of a dispute. One last pitfall that seems to reoccur when drafting which is worth briefly mentioning is when parties give courts and an arbitration center overlapping concurrent jurisdiction. This is inadvisable as it creates the possibility of parallel proceedings being litigated at the same time. It is preferable to include a single forum when drafting an arbitration clause to avoid overlapping and parallel proceedings.
The types of errors highlighted above lead to unnecessary fighting, wasted time and unnecessary costs, all which can be avoided by clear drafting. When drafting an arbitration clause, always ensure that the clause is clear and carefully worded. When parties are endeavoring to draft a contract which includes an arbitration clause where there is the potential that multiple laws may conflict with one another, the parties should always seek legal advice before entering into the contract.
Click here to read Drafting Arbitration Clauses - Part I
Click here to read Drafting Arbitration Clauses - Part II
Tuesday, May 1, 2018
Third-Party Funding - Questions and Answers
With the increase in the use of third-party funding (“TPF”) for litigations and arbitrations across the world, Curtis’ lawyers reached out to Harbour Litigation Funding to gain a better understanding of the workings of third-party funding from the perspective of funders. We had a chat with Ruth Stackpool-Moore, Director of Litigation Funding.
Q: When evaluating whether to fund the legal costs of a claim, what are the key considerations that Harbour takes into consideration?
Having funded claims for over 10 years we have the experience to know that the following factors must be investigated in our initial review:
• the ability of the defendant or the respondent(s) to pay, including consideration of the value of their assets and where they are located – this is of primary importance since success is only success if an award is paid;
• strong legal merits;
• reasonable economics, which we assess by comparing the estimated costs to bring the proceedings, how realistic they are, and what proportion we are being asked to fund with the realistic value of the claim (which will include consideration of the client’s view on reasonable settlement) – we look for a significant gap between the two; and
• the legal team’s experience in the relevant area of law.
It is important to remember that a funder of a claim is taking all of the financial risk. If the claim is unsuccessful, the claimant does not need to repay the legal costs and Harbour’s investment is lost. You can therefore understand why we want to invest in the most experienced lawyers and specialists in the practice area(s) involved.
Q: What do you need to be able to assess the legal merits?
One of our first questions will be: have you received written legal advice, and from whom? In that written advice we would expect to find answers to questions such as: is the case on liability good? Is there a clear basis to claim damages? How long will the case take to come to trial or final hearing? Is settlement a possibility, and how likely?
We focus on understanding the key issues, formulated by the lawyers who have reviewed the wider documentation.
Q: Is there a minimum claim amount that needs to be met in order to receive funding?
We do not work on the basis of a minimum claim value for funding but, rather, we assess the overall economics in any particular case. That will involve a review of the funding required, the value of the claim and sensible settlement expectations. At Harbour, you work with an experienced team of dispute lawyers that has been funding for over a decade. It won’t take us long to talk through your case along the lines explained above. If we think Harbour could fund the dispute, we will immediately discuss the next steps. I would recommend that if you think your case would benefit from funding, the best thing is to contact us for a quick chat. After all, each case is unique.
Q: In our introductory article on TPF last year, concerns of an increase in frivolous claims were raised. What is your take on this?
This is a misconception we hear often, but is simply not true: we don’t back cases unless we believe they will win. If a case is unsuccessful, we lose our investment and therefore it is not in our interest to fund cases that we don’t think will win.
Q: It has also been said that funders aggressively manage the cases they fund, or push for them to go all the way through to hearing or trial, because of the perceived need to deliver a certain return. Is that true?
This is not the case at all at Harbour. We agree our return upfront with the claimant and do not interfere with strategy as the case progresses. It is the claimant and its legal team that run the case. Settlement should be considered at all times, if it is in the best interest of the claimant. As far as we are concerned, having a case determined at hearing or trial represents uncertainty; settlement does not, and is ultimately appealing to us. Ultimately the decision whether to settle or proceed rests with the claimant and its legal team.
Q: Could you offer some examples of the kinds of disputes you fund?
Globally we have funded a wide range of commercial litigation such as breach of contract, breach of statute and competition law, IP and patent disputes, insolvency, fraud-related, tort and trust claims. We also fund international arbitration, both commercial and investor-state, under a number of different sets of arbitral rules in a variety of jurisdictions. In geographies such as Australia and the UK, class actions are another category of claims which receive funding. Such claims can include everything from shareholder claims to product defects to environmental issues causing economic loss or personal injury.
Q: What types of activity have you seen in the Middle East market in the last year?
The team regularly visits the region. For example, in January 2018 one of my colleagues spoke at the World Litigation Forum in Dubai. We regularly receive requests for funding from the Middle East, including Oman, and we have seen interest increase in the last few years. Most of these contacts related to construction claims.
Q: What differentiates Harbour from other funders?
One of the key differences is experience. Harbour has been funding for a long time and our team is made up of lawyers coming from first-class private practices and senior in-house positions. We are also a truly global funder. We have funded in 13 jurisdictions and under four sets of arbitral rules in relation to most areas of law.
This extensive experience, combined with a large amount of capital immediately available, means that when issues arise - as they do in the unpredictable world of dispute resolution - we have the expertise and the capital to deal with them.
Another significant advantage of working with Harbour, and which is not the same for all funders, is that when the Harbour funds invest in a claim, the entire budget is ring-fenced from day one. Our funds are not leveraged. So not only do we have a large amount of capital, immediately available, but we can also guarantee the full budget throughout the life of the case, offering the claimant peace of mind.
Q: Are there any upcoming developments we should be aware of?
We see new users and new uses of funding. TPF has moved from financing impecunious claimants otherwise unable to access justice to well-resourced corporates who are interested in the risk management or hedging qualities of third-party funding.
The positive developments in Singapore, Hong Kong and Dubai related to third-party funding have consolidated its global acceptance. Singapore’s Ministry of Law recently launched a public consultation to seek feedback on the third-party framework they introduced in early 2017 to understand how the system has been received and whether or not its expansion beyond arbitration should be considered, and Hong Kong is expected to clear the final hurdle, implementation of its code of conduct, in Q3 2018.
From Harbour’s own point of view, we launched our fourth fund, with £350 million of additional capital, in March 2018 bringing our total funds raised to £760 million. This new fund gives Harbour even greater flexibility in relation to the cases it can fund, as we are able to address every type of dispute funding from seed money for investigations, single case or portfolio funding to support for even the largest class action and single case budgets.
Monday, April 23, 2018
Assignment as a Form of Security under Omani Law
Introduction
There are a number of different ways in which lenders in Oman can take security over a borrower’s assets so as to help ensure repayment of a loan. These include mortgages over land, commercial mortgages, pledges over shares or bank accounts, and various different types of assignment. Lenders should be aware, however, of the restrictions under Oman law that might affect the nature and enforceability of the available forms of security.
Assignment of rights under Oman law
Neither the assignment of rights nor the assignment of debts (or obligations) had been expressly regulated in Oman until the introduction of the Civil Transactions Law by Sultani Decree 29/2013 (the “Code”). The Code now has provisions governing the assignment of debts, but it still does not address the assignment of rights directly, nor does it set out the requirements for such an assignment.
While the requirements for the assignment of debts are clear under the Code, care must be taken when attempting to assign rights by way of security - and special caution is required when considering the creation of security by way of a purported conditional assignment.
In practice, the assignment of contractual rights is recognised in Oman - based on current commercial custom and comparative law - subject to the terms and conditions of an assignment agreement entered into between the assignor and the assignee, and provided the assignor notifies the debtor of the assignment.
As assignee, the lender should, as a matter of best practice, obtain from the debtor an acknowledgement of the assignment in order to perfect the assignment as a contractual arrangement.
Lenders should note that Oman law does not recognise an assignment as true security, so the assignment need not, indeed cannot, be registered. Accordingly, an assignment of rights will not give a creditor security that can be enforced against other creditors. The assignment is only enforceable against the assignor in contract, and the assignee will rank only as an unsecured creditor in the event of the assignor’s bankruptcy.
Conditional assignment
Under Oman law an assignment must be absolute. Full legal ownership is transferred to the assignee on the effective date of the assignment. A conditional assignment - whereby the secured asset would be transferred to the creditor only in the event of a default by the assignor - might be respected as between the contracting parties, but would be unenforceable against third parties in the event the condition, i.e., default on the obligation secured by the assignment, had not yet been fulfilled.
Lenders should beware the possibility that, in such circumstances, there is at least a theoretical risk that the Oman courts could consider a conditional assignment agreement to be void, notwithstanding the intention of the parties, because its effect would be to transfer title to the secured asset to the creditor before the debt is due to be repaid.
Monday, April 16, 2018
Oman and the Law of the Sea: Part III
In October 2017, the Sultanate of Oman submitted a formal application to the United Nations to extend its continental shelf. The first and second articles in this three-part series outlined the framework of the international Law of the Sea as relevant to Oman and the international legal process involved when a country seeks to expand its marine territory. This third and final article in the series will explore the dynamics behind and potential benefits arising from Oman’s recent application.
While Oman’s formal submission marked only the beginning of the process of review and determination by the United Nations Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf (the “Commission”), the submission was the culmination of a decade-long process of exploration and research by Oman into the possibilities of extending its continental shelf, which requires a detailed science-based submission to be compiled and then presented to the United Nations demonstrating the link between Oman’s landmass and its offshore continental shelf area beyond 200 nautical miles from its coastline.
In 2008, Oman formed its Continental Shelf Boundaries Extension Committee (the “Committee”) following a decision of the Council of Ministers to prioritise the issue. The multidisciplinary Committee spearheaded the application to the Commission and received support from many institutions in Oman, including the Ministries of Foreign Affairs, Defence, Oil and Gas, Commerce and Industry, Legal Affairs, Agriculture and Fisheries, the Interior, Environment and Climate Affairs, Transport and Communication, the Royal Oman Police, the Royal Oman Navy, and Sultan Qaboos University, among others.
In 2013, Oman signed a consultancy and supervision services contract with New Zealand-based hydrocarbons research and exploration company GNS Science. In 2015, Oman awarded a contract to Singapore-based joint venture Gardline CGG to facilitate a marine geotechnical survey which consisted of three technical phases: bathymetry, gravity, and magnetic data acquisition; detailed bathymetry and sub-bottom profiling; and deep water rock dredging. The survey formed the basis of the technical data gathered to inform Oman’s application to the Commission.
While applications to the Commission are incredibly technical and extensive, an Executive Summary of Oman’s application may be viewed on the Commission’s website. The Executive Summary discussed what it terms the “Owen Terrace,” the area of continental shelf comprising the subject matter of the application. The Executive Summary describes the Owen Terrace as being composed of continental crust and rocks that are “by nature and origin the same as those of the landmass of Oman,” but importantly are distinct from the materials found on the deep ocean floor and in the nearby Gulf of Aden.
It is probable that Oman’s investment into the extension of its continental shelf will prove worthwhile. In 2014, after being invited by Oman’s Ministry of Oil and Gas to test within offshore oil and gas exploration blocks, Masirah Oil Limited announced the first offshore oil discovery in the east of Oman after more than three decades of exploration activities. The discovery of the presence of oil off the eastern seaboard has lifted hopes for new hydrocarbon finds in Oman’s largely unexplored offshore domain, which stands to be further enlarged if Oman’s application to the Commission succeeds.
While the timeline of the determination of Oman’s application to the Commission remains unclear, a successful submission would greatly benefit Oman as it would allow the Sultanate to exercise exclusive rights over a large area of seabed in the northern Arabian Sea, including the right to explore for and claim oil and gas and other non-living resources.
Click here to read Oman and the Law of the Sea: Part I
Click here to read Oman and the Law of the Sea: Part II
Monday, April 9, 2018
Know your Business Partners - Part I: Basic Due Diligence Tips
Due diligence, in the legal context, means research and analysis of a company or organisation done in preparation for a business transaction. It normally involves data rooms and complex documents to be analysed and interpreted by a variety of professional consultants to establish assets and liabilities and evaluate the commercial potential of the business.
A full due diligence is a time-consuming and expensive undertaking, usually reserved to major business transactions and not of practical use in the day-to-day business of a company. Nonetheless, in a simpler form, some research and analysis should be part of every company’s process whenever it is considering a new business partner, a new agent or any third party with which it looks to contract. A basic level of information can avoid a number of unpleasant surprises but companies, more often than not, neglect this simple task entirely.
Modern technology enables remote access to public records all over the world and this opportunity should be taken advantage of. In this article we will look at what information can and should be gathered by a foreign company considering doing business with an Omani company. A second article will focus on what information can and should be gathered by an Omani company with respect to a potential foreign business partner.
1. Ministry of Commerce and Industry (“MOCI”)
All Omani legal entities have a unique identification number, the Commercial Registration (“CR”) number. This number may be found in the company’s letterhead, in the company seal and sometimes on the website. If you have the CR number, you can gather basic information about the entity by using the “Search Commercial Registration” section on the MOCI website (business.gov.om). If you don’t have the CR number, you may attempt a search of the entity’s name, bearing in mind that some Omani entities are registered only under their Arabic name and therefore the English name may not return results.
This search will provide basic details, including the form of legal entity, the registration date, the branches/offices of the entity and their locations and the registered activities. It will also show if the entity is “active” or “in liquidation.” The registered activities are identified by the relevant ISIC Codes i.e., the numeric codes set out in International Standard Industrial Classification of all Economic Activities, the international reference classification of productive activities. To verify what the relevant ISIC Codes correspond to and what activities the Omani company is actually authorised to carry out, the same website (business.gov.om) includes a searchable database of the ISIC Codes under Services → Find Business Information → Business Activities List (ISIC).
The information so gathered will provide a preliminary overview of the company’s experience, the existence of offices/shops in various locations, and the business activities the company is licensed to carry out. Further information, including the share capital, the names of the partners and the names of the authorised signatories are set out in the entity’s CR Certificate, which can be obtained from the MOCI. As online access from abroad is difficult, the Omani entity directly or, if preferable, another locally established contact person may be asked to procure a copy of the Certificate.
2. Muscat Securities Market (“MSM”)
Omani companies are generally not required to publish their financial statements. An exception to this general rule relates to listed joint stock companies, locally identified by the acronym SAOG (the full company name will be “Company XYZ SAOG”). If you are considering contracting with a “SAOG,” the MSM website will provide a wealth of information, including mandatory disclosures, composition of the board and financial statements. Through the search box of msm.gov.om you will find the company’s dedicated page, where you can browse the “News” section and the “Financial Reports” section.
3. Tender Board
If you are interested in business opportunities involving government contracts, it is recommended that you make yourself familiar with the rules applicable to public tendering in Oman. To simplify, the Omani government and its entities may issue international or local tenders. International tenders, usually for either massive projects or highly specialised contracts, are open to foreign companies regardless of the presence of an entity registered in Oman. Conversely, local tenders are reserved to companies incorporated in Oman and registered with the Oman Tender Board. If your proposed Omani partner is being selected with a view to participating together in government tenders, you should check if such partner is actually registered with the Tender Board and, if so, for which activities and with what grade. This will ensure that the partner will actually be able to purchase the tender documents and participate in the tender, usually with your company as joint venture partner or sub-contractor. Contractors, for example, may be classified in descending order from Excellent Grade to Fourth Grade; only Excellent Grade companies have access to all tenders.
The website etendering.tenderboard.gov.om publishes a list of the registered companies. It also publishes and updates a list of tenders.
4. OPAL
If your interest is in the Oil & Gas sector, you may consider checking whether your proposed business partner is a member of OPAL, the Oman Society for Petroleum Services, which has, among its members, the most reputable companies of the sector. Please note that membership in OPAL is required in order to be awarded certain projects; therefore, it is useful to know whether your local partner is a member. A members’ list is available at opaloman.org. In the same sector, one should ascertain that all applicable procedures in respect of the Oil & Gas Joint Supplier Registration System are complied with (more information on this can be found on businessgateways.com).
As part of the ongoing e-government initiative, all websites mentioned in this article have an English version and are rather modern and user-friendly. Still, always allow for spelling issues (names are often transliterated between English and Arabic with variable results) and provide for assistance as some documents, such as CR Certificates, are not entirely translated into English.
Finally, from the very beginning of negotiations with a potential local partner, if you cannot find the information you need or some of your findings raise questions, do not be afraid to ask questions!
Click here to read Know your Business Partners - Part II: Basic Due Diligence Tips
Monday, April 2, 2018
Drafting Arbitration Clauses - Part II: Ad Hoc or Administered Arbitration
Introduction
When drafting an arbitration clause, the choice of “ad hoc” or “administered” arbitration (also known as institutional arbitration) is a critical issue that parties should consider. Both ad hoc and administered arbitrations have their own advantages. This article will outline some of the key characteristics of each of them.
Ad hoc
Ad hoc arbitration is an arbitration framework that is defined by the agreement between the parties (subject to the law of the place of the arbitration). Ad hoc arbitration is more flexible than administered arbitration as the arbitral framework is based on party autonomy rather than institutional rules. Ad hoc arbitration is also less expensive than institutional arbitration as there is no institution to which fees need to be paid, which is a major reason many people opt for ad hoc arbitration. In ad hoc arbitration the parties must agree on all facets of the arbitral framework that are otherwise provided for under institutional arbitration, including tribunal fees and procedural deadlines.
When parties agree to ad hoc arbitration, they often also agree to a certain set of arbitral rules that will apply and can be used as guidance for the framework for the arbitration, but this is not always the case. When the parties do not agree to a set of arbitral rules to govern the procedure or the parties agree to a set of rules that does not address a particular aspect of an arbitration, the law of the seat of arbitration (the legal jurisdiction to which the arbitration is tied) will be used in conjunction with the agreement of the parties. For example, in Oman if parties fail to agree on an arbitrator, the statutory appointing authority is the Oman courts. Much can be said for the flexibility and party autonomy to define the procedural framework of each arbitration.
Administered arbitration
Administered arbitrations are arbitrations that are administered by an arbitration centre. Arbitration centres play a number of roles when administering arbitrations and offer various services to the parties aimed at providing efficiency to the arbitral process. Each arbitration centre has its own set of rules that guide the arbitral procedure. Each centre has a secretariat in place to assist with administrative and logistical tasks, as well as a body which deals with high-level issues such as challenges to the appointment of arbitrators when parties cannot agree on who will be appointed.
Most sets of arbitral rules provide a fee scale or other mechanism setting out how much tribunals are to be paid.** Often, the fixed fees for arbitrators are calculated based on the amount in dispute. These fees can be advantageous to parties in terms of the certainty of the costs of arbitration. Similarly, ad hoc arbitrations in Oman are often based on fixed fees.
Another important role that the arbitration centres fulfil is the mechanism for collection of fees for arbitrators. At various stages throughout the arbitration, a centre will ask the parties for advances on arbitrator fees that are held in escrow and paid to the arbitrators. Collecting these fees removes the burdensome administrative task of collecting and holding funds from the jurisdiction of the arbitrators in an ad hoc arbitration.
Another major advantage of administered arbitration is the scrutiny of arbitral awards, which is a service provided by some arbitration centres including the International Chamber of Commerce and the Singapore International Arbitration Centre. Following the tribunal issuing its award, the secretariat of the arbitration centre will review the award for any major errors. This is done for various reasons including quality control and to ensure that an award is not set aside. While this may seem to be a minor feature that is provided by an arbitration centre, it drastically reduces the likelihood that an award will be unenforceable.
Further considerations
One of the most significant factors parties ought to consider when deciding whether to opt for ad hoc or administered arbitration is the degree of supervision that may be required over the arbitration.
While ad hoc arbitration provides for a greater degree of party autonomy and flexibility, this can also lead to a higher risk of the arbitration proceedings getting derailed by a party that does not want to participate in the proceedings. For example, in institutional arbitration, if a party is engaging in dilatory tactics the arbitration centre in its supervisory capacity will be able to step in and ensure that the arbitration stays on track. This does not always hold true in ad hoc arbitration. It can be said that administered arbitration follows a tried and tested framework while ad hoc arbitration is based on flexibility, and relies to a greater degree on party consent. In most cases administered arbitration is preferred over ad hoc arbitration.
In Oman both ad hoc and institutional arbitration are used. Given the significant differences between the two, parties should carefully consider whether to choose ad hoc or administered arbitration when drafting their arbitration clauses, having regard to each contract’s circumstances and nature.
**The London Court of International Arbitration Rules use hourly rates, and under the Hong Kong International Arbitration Center Rules parties can opt for hourly rates or fixed fees.
Click here to read Drafting Arbitration Clauses - Part I
Click here to read Drafting Arbitration Clauses - Part III
Monday, March 26, 2018
New Register for Overseas Companies Owning UK Property or Bidding for UK Government Contracts
The UK government is to establish a register to show the true beneficial ownership of overseas companies that own, or propose to own, UK property in order to bolster the reputation and integrity of the UK property market. The register will be the first of its kind in the world and will require overseas companies that own or buy property in the UK, or who wish to participate in UK government procurement, to provide details of their ultimate owners.
Generally speaking, these include shareholders with more than 25% of the shares or voting rights in a corporate entity; or individuals, such as directors or managers, who otherwise exercise significant influence or control over the entity.
The UK has already taken major steps to increase corporate transparency, with the introduction of the “people with significant control” (PSC) register, a public register of those who control UK companies. Now UK property is being brought into play in the battle against money laundering. It is hoped that the register will minimise opportunities for criminals to use anonymous shell companies to launder criminal proceeds via UK properties, and will make it easier for law enforcement agencies to track illegal funds.
The new register will apply to both existing and future property ownership, and to freehold and leasehold properties of more than 21 years. Overseas entities that have not been registered will not be able to charge or grant, let alone buy or sell, a long lease of UK property. Entities that already own UK property when the legislation comes into effect will be given a year to comply with its requirements, or to sell if they do not want to do so. At the end of the year, any such entities will be prevented from selling their property or from creating a long lease or charge if they have not registered, and a restriction will be put on the title accordingly.
Further, overseas entities which have not provided information about their beneficial owners to the UK’s Companies House will not be able to bid for UK government contracts. Bids for UK government contracts by overseas entities which fail to include information on the bidder’s beneficial ownership will be excluded and, if received, will be rejected as incomplete or non-compliant.
The proposals are also intended to apply across the UK, in England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. While Scotland has set forth similar proposals separately, the UK government indicates that it will work with the devolved administrations as the proposals develop.
The new register will be held by Companies House. Once registered, overseas entities will be given a registration number. The Land Registry will not register the title of an overseas company without a valid registration number. Anyone will be able to check the register free of charge.
The government has committed to publishing a draft bill this summer and introducing it in Parliament by next summer.
This will be a significant consideration for overseas companies investing in UK property or bidding for UK government contracts, so that the registration process does not end up causing delay, or preventing a purchase from being registered. Evidence of registration will need to be sought early on, and before the exchange of contracts.
Monday, March 19, 2018
Oman and the Law of the Sea: Part II
In October 2017, the Sultanate of Oman submitted a formal application to the United Nations to extend its continental shelf. The first article in this three-part series outlined the framework of the international Law of the Sea as relevant to Oman. This second installment outlines the international legal process involved when a country seeks to expand its marine territory.
While Oman’s formal submission marked the end of a decade-long process of exploration and research, it marked only the beginning of the process of review and determination by the United Nations Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf (the “Commission”), part of the United Nations Division for Ocean Affairs and Law of the Sea. Established in 1997, the Commission is neither a judicial nor a political body, but rather an advisory group that gives technical guidance to states seeking to expand their continental shelves. The advice given by the Commission is based on the technical and objective criteria set out in the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea (the “Convention”).
The Commission is comprised of 21 experts from the fields of geology, geophysics or hydrography, who are elected by state parties to the Convention. The Commissioners serve five-year terms and volunteer significant time to assess the scientific and technical validity of the applications and data submitted by each coastal state. Among the Commission’s current members is an Omani, Dr. Adnan Rashid Al-Azri. The Commission holds two sessions per year at the United Nations headquarters in New York.
The Commission’s purpose is to consider the documentation submitted by the coastal state and to make recommendations regarding the outer limits of the continental shelf. After the state submits its application, the Commission waits three months to begin review to give interested parties, such as bordering states, time to consider any responses. After the three-month period, the Commission meets with a delegation from the submitting state, during which the state presents its submission and answers any preliminary questions from the Commission. The Commission then appoints a sub-commission of seven members to carry out a detailed review. Commission members from the concerned coastal state or its bordering states may not sit on the sub-commission. The sub-commission then meets as many times as necessary to complete a full technical and scientific review, which is not constrained by any time limits. During this process, the sub-commission may request further information or clarification from the submitting state or from outside legal or technical experts. The sub-commission considers each of the criteria established by the Convention and determines whether the state has submitted data sufficient to lay claim to an extension of its continental shelf. After completing its review, the sub-commission drafts recommendations on the proposed limits and passes these along to the full Commission.
After in-depth consideration and discussion by the Commission during its biannual sessions, the Commission decides whether to adopt the sub-commission’s recommendations regarding the delineation of the relevant state’s continental shelf. The process of consideration, requests for more information, and reconsideration can take years, depending on the technical complexity of the determination. After the Commission makes a formal recommendation, it is then incumbent upon the applicant state to promulgate national law effectuating the Commission’s recommendations. If the state disagrees with the Commission’s recommendations, it can resubmit its claim to the Commission for a new set of recommendations.
Although the extension of a state’s continental shelf limits is a matter of sovereign state law, the need for the Commission’s consideration and recommendation is twofold. First, the assessment and determination of submarine geographical bounds is a complex scientific and technical process requiring expert investigation, information gathering, and data analyses, and the Commission serves as a vital resource for coastal states which may not otherwise have access to such expertise. Second, the Commission acts as a safeguard of what the Convention has termed the “common heritage of mankind” – the seabed, ocean floor, subsoil, and resources beyond the outer limit of the continental shelf.
Coastal states do not have an unlimited right to submit applications expanding their continental shelf. Rather, the Convention provides that each coastal state seeking to expand its continental shelf must submit an application within ten years of the Convention coming into force for the state in question. However, given the technical complexity and financial demands of gathering data and forming a submission, many countries pushed for an extension of that deadline, at least for developing countries. Collectively, the parties to the Convention decided that applicant states could satisfy the ten-year deadline by submitting preliminary findings on their outer limits, a description of the status of their progress, and an intended final submission date. This decision spurred a raft of new placeholder applications, making it likely that the Commission will be reviewing submissions and resubmissions for at least the next decade.
The Commission is restricted to giving advice to determine the outer limits of a state’s continental shelf, and by its own procedural rules is not permitted to influence any potential dispute related to the delimitation of the shelf between two or more states. All recommendations of the Commission are made without prejudice to maritime boundary delimitation between states themselves. As this is often a sensitive area, applicant states are permitted to classify as confidential any data and other material forming part of its application.
An example of the sensitive and high-stakes nature of these issues can be seen in the outcry following the very first submission to the Commission, which was the Russian Federation’s 2001 claim over extensive portions of the Arctic Circle. This raised the ire and concern of countries such as Canada and Norway who also had claims over the Arctic but had not yet submitted applications to the Commission. Ultimately, the Commission rejected large portions of Russia’s claims over the Arctic and the contentious issue remains unresolved.
The third and final installment in this series will examine Oman’s recent submission to the Commission and will discuss the potential benefits to Oman of extending its continental shelf, which include the right to explore for oil and gas and other non-living resources.
Click here to read Oman and the Law of the Sea: Part I
Click here to read Oman and the Law of the Sea: Part III
Monday, March 12, 2018
U.S. Customs and Border Protection: Search of Electronic Devices
On 4 January 2018, the United States (“U.S.”) Customs and Border Protection (“CBP”) issued Directive No. 3340-049A superseding Directive 3340-049 to standardise procedures its officers use during border searches, which include searches of all persons entering the U.S. through airports (the “Directive”). Pursuant to the Directive, the CBP has authority to conduct “routine searches of the persons and effects of entrants [into the U.S. which] are not subject to any requirement of reasonable suspicion, probable cause, or warrant.” In effect, this means the CDP may conduct border searches of electronic devices, such as laptops, tablets, and mobile phones.
This article outlines why business travellers should be aware of the Directive, and sets out the steps a business traveller can take to protect information they store on their digital devices when entering the U.S.
Privileged material
Entrants into the U.S. should be particularly aware of Section 5.2 of the Directive, which covers privileged material. Section 5.2 sets procedures for CBP officers to follow when encountering material asserted to be protected by the attorney-client privilege or the attorney work product doctrine. Officers should first clarify with the owner of the electronic device which files are specifically protected by a privilege. Officers cannot search any privileged material without first contacting the CBP Chief Counsel office and establishing a Filter Team, composed of both legal and non-legal CBP personnel, to assist in segregating privileged materials from other files.
Searches can be basic or advanced. Basic searches are those conducted without the aid of external equipment CBP personnel use to review, copy, or analyse the device’s contents. They should be conducted in the presence of the device’s owner unless there are safety concerns rendering the owner’s presence inappropriate. Advanced searches are searches requiring external equipment to review the device. They require reasonable suspicion of unlawful activity.
Once CBP officers complete their search of an electronic device, they must destroy any privileged materials that they have copied. Business or commercial information should be treated similarly and protected from unauthorised disclosure.
Business travellers
Business travellers who are stopped by CBP while entering the U.S. may consider taking the following steps:
• insist that any basic searches be conducted in their presence;
• tell the CBP officers that they do not want the device to leave their sight;
• call a legal adviser if necessary to ensure compliance with the Directive;
• ask the purpose and authority for a border search;
• ask to report concerns and seek redress from the CBP, if necessary;
• ask for a receipt if a device is detained by CBP officers who are entitled to detain devices for up to five days; and
• enter their own passcode or encryption key into a device instead of divulging it to CBP officers.
If a business traveller has on them any privileged, confidential, or trade secret information contained on the device or devices subject to search by CBP officers, they should advise CBP personnel performing the search.
How can sensitive information be protected?
In order to facilitate the protection of sensitive information, it may prove helpful to segregate privileged, confidential, or trade secret information to a single, clearly labeled folder or directory when traveling internationally, so that the information can be easily identified to CBP and treated in accordance with the Directive.
As the Directive requires entrants to provide log-in and password information, encryption or password protection will not be a useful tactic for protecting sensitive information. One possible method of protection is not to store any privileged materials on your electronic devices at all. Retaining privileged documents in a password-protected secure cloud server or a remote file-saving system ensures that CBP, when searching your device, cannot access any protected material.
Section 5.1 of the Directive permits officers to search “only the information that is resident upon the device and accessible through the device’s operating system or through other software, tools, or applications.” This means that CBP officers cannot access information that is solely stored remotely, and must either enable airplane mode or disable internet connectivity before searching a device. Any person travelling to the U.S. should themselves ensure their devices are in airplane mode, or insist that CBP personnel disable their devices’ connectivity before conducting a search. This both protects remote files and prevents downloading of harmful malware. Any remotely stored information that is synced with the device’s operating system is, however, accessible; only remote information that is not downloaded will be protected.
Conclusion
In an effort to respond to the evolving world of information technology, the Directive aims to enhance the transparency, accountability and oversight of electronic device border searches performed by CBP. Business travellers who frequently participate in international travel may wish to consider the scope of the Directive, especially if the traveller’s electronic device(s) contain confidential or sensitive work-related information.