Tuesday, August 14, 2012

Agency Disputes

It is often thought that an agency relationship is the best way for a foreign entity to do business in Oman.

However, this is incorrect.

Under Omani law, the purpose of an agency is for a foreign entity’s goods to be promoted and/or sold in Oman. An agency is not supposed to involve the physical presence in Oman of the foreign entity. The expectation of the legislator is that the Omani agent will import the goods into Oman and sell them within Oman, without personnel of the foreign entity physically being in Oman.

In reality, there are many instances in which a foreign principal wants its representatives to be in Oman, based on an agency relationship.

This normally means that the Omani agent becomes the sponsor and employer of the individuals sent to Oman by the foreign principal. This can cause problems for both parties. For instance, the agent may terminate the worker given that the worker, whilst in Oman, is a bona fide employee of the agent, rather than of the principal.

Alternatively, the foreign principal may instruct the Omani agent to dismiss the worker. The agent then complies with this directive, only to be hit with an unfair dismissal claim by the worker. This may cause difficulties if the foreign principal is unwilling to fund a lawyer to defend the agent in the Omani courts. The agent also may face problems if the foreign principal refuses to provide the funds necessary to satisfy any final, non-appealable Omani court judgment made against the agent in its role as Omani employer.

There also have been instances in which agents have filed spurious criminal complaints in Oman against the workers sent by the foreign principal, in a bid to gain leverage in any dispute with the foreign principal.

Another aspect to consider is tax. The Tax Authority may take the view that the presence of the foreign principal’s representatives in Oman is sufficient to deem that the foreign entity has set up a permanent establishment in Oman from the tax perspective. However, if the foreign entity refuses to pay Omani income tax, there is a possibility that the Tax Authority may pursue the Omani agent for that tax.

In conclusion, any situation which involves workers of a foreign entity being sponsored in Oman by a local entity can cause problems. Omani legal advice should be sought before entering into any such arrangement.


Read More...



Wednesday, August 8, 2012

Share Pledges - Part 1

This article considers which shares can be pledged under Omani law, the process of registering a share pledge, dealing with pledged shares, how to release a share pledge, and finally how a share pledge can be enforced.

Which Shares Can be Pledged?

The shares in a joint stock company may be pledged under the Omani Law of Commerce. It is not possible to pledge shares in a limited liability company or partnership as such shares may not be represented by negotiable instruments and are more akin to a “participating interest” than shares.Shares in an open joint stock company must to be registered on the Muscat Securities Market (MSM) by the Muscat Clearing & Depository SAOC (Muscat Depository) and shares in a closed joint stock company need to be registered before such shares can be transferred or pledged.

Process of Registering a Share Pledge

The registration requirements for a share pledge are controlled by the Muscat Depository and, currently, the entity receiving the share pledge (the lender or the pledgee) has to register and open an account initially with the Muscat Depository by providing copies, suitably authenticated, of its corporate documents, a letter requesting the opening of an account and the completed application form. It will then receive a depository number from the Muscat Depository.

The share pledge is usually registered in a standard lien form in Arabic. The standard lien only provides details of the following:

  • • the pledgor (the entity granting the share pledge);
  • • the pledgee;
  • • the name of the company whose shares are being pledged and the number of shares; and
  • • whether cash profit (cash dividends) and free shares (stock dividends) are pledged or not.
Other conditions can be inserted in to the final clause (Clause 3: Other Conditions). We would recommend that various additional terms are included in the share pledge including a description of the obligations secured by the share pledge.

The share pledge needs to be executed by the pledgor and the pledgee and, if a party is a foreign entity, the execution of the share pledge needs to be suitably authenticated. Then, the share pledge itself can be registered by lodging it with the Muscat Depository together with the various documents including a list of authorised signatories and the commercial registration papers of the pledgor and the pledgee. Again, if a party is a foreign entity any corporate documents will need to be suitably authenticated.

The share pledge will take effect from the date it is registered by the Muscat Depository and they will issue a Statement of Account for the pledgor, showing the pledged shares. Prior to the registration of the share pledge, the share pledge will take effect as a private contract between the parties only.

Next month, Part II of this article will discuss certain key aspects of Omani share pledges, such as how they may be dealt with, released, and enforced.

Read More...



Wednesday, August 1, 2012

Islamic Banking: Home Purchase Financings I - The Lease

This is the second in our continuing series of articles on basic Islamic banking, finance and investment concepts. This article, and subsequent articles, begin to explore the palette of products that are available to customers of Shari`ah-compliant banks. It seems appropriate to begin with hearth and home, which is a fundamental focus of individuals, banks and other finance providers, the business community and governments. It is a topic of acute interest in the Middle East at the moment as a result of the recent adoption of a mortgage law in Saudi Arabia. As a result of that law, housing finance in Saudi Arabia is anticipated to grow, and constitute an entirely new industry. 1 That development is expected to enfranchise a significant portion of the Saudi population as home financing becomes available and the Saudi population moves to home ownership and enhanced participation in the Saudi economic system. The mortgage law implements Shari`ah-compliant rahn- concepts and will stimulate the growth of Shari`ah-compliant home financing, and thus the growth of Islamic banking. Spill-over stimuli in surrounding countries is inevitable. And, as one of their first products, Islamic banks in the Sultanate of Oman will likely offer home purchase financing.

We will summarize five of the most frequently used home purchase financing structures provided by Islamic banks. They are: (a) the lease (ijara); (b) the diminishing partnership or diminishing musharaka (musharaka mutanaqisa); (c) the cost-plus sale (murabaha); (d) the deferred payment sale (bay bithaman ajil), which is used in Malaysia and Indonesia but only infrequently elsewhere; and (e) the two-tier construction contract financing (istisna – parallel istisna), which is a construction financing structure rather than a purchase structure.

Some of these structures are used in Islamic banking, finance and investment transactions other than home purchase financing. Accordingly, this and subsequent articles discuss each of these structures in some detail before moving on to other structures.

Lease Financing: In Principle

The lease (ijara) financing structure is the most widely used Shari`ah-compliant structure in the world for sophisticated financings. It is simple in concept. An Islamic Bank (usually through a surrogate) purchases a house using the Bank’s funds (in the leverage amount, say, 75% of the house purchase price) and funds from the Home Buyer (in the down payment amount of, say, 25% of the purchase price).

The acquisition of the house is illustrated in FIGURE 1: PURCHASE OF HOUSE (a surrogate purchase, through a “Funding Company” is illustrated).


In the Figure 1 example, the house is owned by the Bank surrogate, the Funding Company. The house is then leased to the prospective Home Buyer for a period of time (say, 15 or 30 years). The Bank’s return is the profit on the lease. The lease rent schedule will be quite similar to a conventional home purchase financing amortization schedule. If the Home Buyer makes all its rental payments over the term, the Home Buyer may purchase and take title to the home for a further final payment, which is usually nominal.

The making of multiple rent payments, the use of those rent payments to make payments on the bank financing, the making of the final purchase payment, and the transfer of title to the Home Buyer are illustrated in FIGURE 2: RENT, FINANCING AND PURCHASE PAYMENTS. 2


This article assumes that the Funding Company is a disregarded entity for income tax purposes. That is not the case in many jurisdictions, and in those jurisdictions additional expense items are structured at the Funding Company level to offset the “rental income” of the Funding Company.

An ijara is a lease of an object or services involving the transfer of the usufruct or manfa’a (the use of an object or the services of a person) for a rent consideration. The nature of the usufruct must be precisely defined, the rental consideration must be for a fixed value, 3 whether payable in a lump sum or installments, and the term of the lease must be precisely determined. Both the rent and the term must be clearly ascertained and designated in the lease. The rent may escalate or diminish during the term so long as the amounts of such escalation and/or decrease are specified and known to both parties. 4 The lessor is responsible for structural maintenance of the assets and correlative obligations (e.g., casualty insurance) and these obligations may not be passed to the lessee pursuant to the lease. The lessor is entitled to receive its rent as long as the lessee has the enjoyment of the leased assets as specified in the lease, but not after termination of the lease.

Lease Documentation

FIGURE 3: GENERIC IJARA (LEASE) FINANCING: DOCUMENTATION summarizes the documentary structure for a lease structure (without security documentation).


The structure depicted in Figure 3 is of a generic home financing transaction. However, this structure (in various iterations) is used in a wide range of transactions, including financings of real estate, petrochemical, electricity, mining and infrastructure projects, among others. It is also the base structure for private equity transactions. It is used in Middle Eastern, North American, European and Asian jurisdictions.

The lease structure may be a “bifurcated structure” involving a conventional loan arrangement for leverage (or gearing), or purely Shari`ah-compliant. Referring to Figure 3, a bifurcated structure will entail a conventional interest-bearing loan from the Bank to the Funding Company pursuant to the Financing Documents (to the left of the dotted red line). All documents and transactions to the right of the dotted red line will then be compliant with the Shari`ah. Bifurcated structures are quite common as they allow conventional banks to participate in Shari`ah-compliant transactions. 5 The reasons for the widespread acceptance of this structure by interest-based financiers are apparent: those financiers make conventional loans, as they would in any financing; the relevant credit, underwriting and risk criteria are essentially the same as in any conventional financing, as is the analyses of those elements; there are no changes to financial reporting conventions; and there are no changes to the financier’s back office operations. The entirely compliant version is more frequently encountered in jurisdictions within the Organisation for Islamic Cooperation.

In most jurisdictions, banks are not permitted to own real property. 6 In order to take control of a house (and related land) for the purpose of leasing it to a home purchaser, the bank will arrange to have the property owned in a special purpose entity (each, a “Funding Company”) by a third party. 7 While title to the house (and possibly the land) will be in the Funding Company, that entity will usually have no ability to make any decisions or determinations with respect to the property; all such decisions and determinations will be made by the Bank, a process that is established and controlled pursuant to the Financing Documents.


As noted above, and in Figure 1, the Home Buyer will inject a down payment and the Bank will provide the leverage financing. In a bifurcated structure, the leverage will be in the form of a conventional interest-bearing loan. If an Islamic Bank is providing the leverage financing, the structure for the contribution of funds by the Bank will vary from one jurisdiction to another. For example, the Bank may inject equity funds into the Funding Company. Or the Bank may purchase a sukuk issued by a Funding Company or another vehicle that effectively securitizes the rent flows from one or more Funding Companies. Alternatively, the Bank may take a participation interest in a Funding Company, with the profit being all of the rent flow on the Lease (Ijara) between that Funding Company and its related Home Buyer(s). Or the Bank may structure a musharaka or mudaraba arrangement that controls the Funding Company, with essentially all of the profits (derived from rental income) of the musharaka or mudaraba going to the Bank.

The Funding Company will lease the project assets to the Home Buyer pursuant to the Lease (Ijara). The basic rent payable by the Home Buyer to the Funding Company under the Lease (Ijara) will be structured to be exactly equivalent to the debt service payable by the Funding Company to the Bank under the Financing Documents (and related documents).

The transaction will be structured such that any default on the Lease (Ijara) (and related documents) will constitute an event of default under the Financing Documents. That is relatively easy to achieve by inserting a cross-default to the Lease (Ijara) as an event of default in the Financing Documents. The obverse is more difficult to achieve because applicable Shari`ah precepts preclude having one of the Lease events of default being a Financing Document event of default. The earliest structures achieved the desired result by mirroring, with precision, the representations, warranties, covenants and other provisions of the Financing Documents in the Lease (Ijara) and related documents. This was a tedious and costly process and more expeditious methods of achieving this result have since been developed.

The Understanding to Purchase is a Shari`ah-compliant sale and purchase agreement that allows the Funding Company, at the direction of the Bank, to cause the Home Buyer to purchase the house upon a Lease event of default (and upon the occurrence of any other mandatory prepayment provision). This is necessary because the Shari`ah prohibits acceleration of future rents, and future rents will include all the outstanding principal of the financing at any given time. The purchase price will be equal to the outstanding principal under the Financing Documents from time to time. The Home Buyer may also desire to prepay the financing, in whole or in part. The Understanding to Sell is a purchase and sale agreement that allows this result. The purchase price will be equal to the amount of the financing prepayment at any given point in time. In the case of each Understanding, the purchase price will be initially paid by the Home Buyer to the Funding Company; the Funding Company will then use those funds to make payment under the Financing Documents.

Shari`ah principles and precepts applicable to leasing preclude the lessor from passing structural maintenance obligations (and correlative obligations) to the lessee pursuant to the Lease (Ijara), thereby precluding “triple-net” leasing that is so common in Western financial arrangements. To bring the Shari`ah-compliant financing transaction into harmony with existing Western markets, a mechanism is invoked to shift the structural maintenance obligations (and correlative obligations) to the Home Buyer (lessee). This occurs in the Managing Contractor Agreement where the Funding Company (lessor) hires the Home Buyer to perform structural maintenance and to undertake defined correlative obligations.

The Managing Contractor Agreement contains a second set of provisions that address the making of decisions and determinations and the direction of actions by the Funding Company. Basically, these provisions provide that any decision or determination to be made by the Funding Company (a) with respect to the Lease (Ijara) and the Understanding to Purchase will be made by the Bank, 8 and (b) with respect to the Financing Documents will be made by the Home Buyer. The result is the removal of the Funding Company from decision-making. Of course, nothing is quite so simple as one would like. Frequently, the Bank is not willing to make these decisions and determinations on behalf of, or to direct actions by, the Funding Company. This reluctance may relate to liability concerns or internal institutional practices. Similarly, for Shari`ah reasons, the Home Buyer is unable to make decisions and determinations and have responsibilities in respect of the Financing Documents and related conventional interest-bearing arrangements. Harmonization of these positions with the principle stated in the first two sentences of this paragraph entails some careful structuring and drafting, but is achieved in the Managing Contractor Agreement.

Collateral Security

Collateral security structures for the lease transaction are quite similar to those in a conventional interest-based home financing, although the exact structures will vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction.

FIGURE 4: COLLATERAL SECURITY graphically depicts a generic collateral security structure for a lease-based financing.


There is a mortgage from the Funding Company to the Bank with respect to all right, title, interest and estate of the Funding Company in and to the house and the land. In addition, the Funding Company will collaterally assign to the Bank whatever collateral security the Funding Company received from the Home Buyer. This security package will secure the obligations of Funding Company to the Bank under the Financing Documents, i.e., the repayment of the financing. It is exercisable by the Bank upon an event of default under the Financing Documents.

The Home Buyer will provide to the Funding Company a security interest in and to all of the Home Buyer’s right, title, interest and estate in and to the house and the land. That security interest may also include other assets of the Home Buyer, possibly including monies in the Home Buyer’s bank accounts. It also may include a personal guarantee of the Home Buyer in respect of the rent and purchase payments. These security interests are exercisable by the Funding Company (at the direction of the Bank) upon a Lease event of default, but not a Financing Document event of default that is not a Lease event of default. This collateral may not secure the Financing Document obligations, only certain Lease and related obligations.

Future articles

Our next Client Alert article will continue the discussion of Shari`ah-compliant home purchasing financing products. We will take up diminishing musharaka structures and murabaha structures and then move to istisna` – parallel istisna` structures.

As the Sultanate of Oman prepares to roll out its new legal and regulatory framework for Islamic banking in the coming months, we will be covering Islamic banking in the Client Alert as it is an important and growing field. This article is the second in a series by Curtis partner Michael J.T. McMillen, an Islamic finance specialist based in our New York office who provides support to our Islamic banking practice in Oman and throughout the Middle East region.

1. The long-awaited Saudi mortgage law was approved by the Council of Ministers of the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia on July 2, 2012. The draft of that law that was approved by the Shura Council is analyzed in Michael J.T. McMillen, Rahn Concepts in Saudi Arabia, Formalization and a Registration and Prioritization System, available at http://ssrrn.com/abstract=1670104. It is currently unknown if the final version varies from that draft. A structure used to obtain and enforce rahn (mortgage and pledge under the Shari`ah) in Saudi Arabia, without regard to the new law, is discussed in Michael J.T. McMillen, Islamic Shari’ah-Compliant Project Finance: Collateral Security and Financing Structure Case Studies, 24 FORDHAM INT’L L.J. 1184 (2001). ↩
2. This article assumes that the Funding Company is a disregarded entity for income tax purposes. That is not the case in many jurisdictions, and in those jurisdictions additional expense items are structured at the Funding Company level to offset the “rental income” of the Funding Company ↩
3. Variable rate leasing arrangements are widely used, and are expressly authorized in Ijāra Standard, § 5/2/3, of the Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions (“AAOIFI”) ↩
4. The rent may not increase as a result of delays in payment of the rent (see, e.g., AAOIFI Ijāra Standard, at § 6/3) although an “interest” or “late payment” charge may be imposed if it is donated to charity (see, e.g., AAOIFI Ijāra Standard, at § 6/4). ↩
5. Consider, for example, Western jurisdictions that have no Islamic banks ↩
6. Other than certain specific and limited categories of properties: for example, those necessary for the bank’s operations (e.g., offices) and, on a temporary basis, those that have been foreclosed upon .↩
7. Often the Funding Company is owned by a corporate service company. Ideally, there will be one Funding Company for each property, which isolates liability, bankruptcy, tax and other exposures on a per-property basis. In many jurisdictions, it is difficult to establish corporate (or limited liability company) vehicles and one Funding Company may hold multiple properties, each leased to a different Home Buyer. Other important concerns relate to tax treatment in each specific jurisdiction. For example, will a Funding Company be a taxable entity or an entity that is disregarded for tax purposes? Will the Funding Company or the Home Buyer be the tax owner for local law purposes? The reasons for the widespread acceptance of this structure by Western financiers is apparent: those financiers make conventional loans, as they would in any construction (or acquisition or other equivalent) financing; the relevant credit, underwriting and risk criteria are essentially the same as in any conventional financing, as is the analyses of those elements; there are no changes to financial reporting conventions; and there are no changes to the financier’s back-office operations. Considerations of the types mentioned in this note, while critical, are not discussed in this introductory article. ↩
8. The Bank should not and will not make decisions or determinations with respect to (a) the Understanding to Sell or (b) the Managing Contractor Agreement itself. The former allows the Home Buyer to prepay the financing by way of voluntary prepayment. These rights are unrestricted in conventional financings and the Shari`ah-compliant should be in no more of a disadvantageous situation. The decision-making provisions of the Managing Contractor Agreement are self-effecting in all situations, including non-default and default scenarios, and those arrangements should not be modified by security documents that shift decision-making to the Bank in all default circumstances. ↩

Read More...



Friday, July 13, 2012

Article on Islamic Finance by Curtis Partner Michael J.T. McMillen Published in New York Law Journal

One of the Firm's New York-based partners, Michael J.T. McMillen, who supports Curtis Oman's Islamic Finance practice, recently published an article in the New York Law Journal that might be of interest to our Omani and other GCC readers who are looking to invest in US real estate projects and corporate entities via a Shariah-compliant vehicle:

Islamic Finance and Investment in U.S. Expected to Grow

Read More...



Wednesday, July 11, 2012

Land Law Update: Royal Decree Allows Expansion of Property Size

Over the last few years the Omani authorities have taken numerous steps toward liberalizing the rules for expatriate ownership of real estate in the Sultanate. Over the last few years the Omani authorities have taken numerous steps toward liberalizing the rules for expatriate ownership of real estate in the Sultanate.

Just two years ago, for example, the Government significantly relaxed the restrictions on landholding for Omani joint-stock companies with foreign ownership. Joint-stock stock companies with real estate development among their corporate objects and with foreign shareholding of up to 70 percent were granted the right to own land on a freehold basis for the purpose of real estate development. Prior to the change, only joint-stock companies with at least 51 percent Omani shareholding had been allowed to own land in Oman – and only for purposes subservient to the company’s business objects, such as for showroom, warehouse or administrative office space or for employee housing. This pivotal new rule made it possible for Omani real estate development companies with foreign shareholding to directly transfer freehold ownership to their purchasers or their units.

The Government has also broadened land ownership rights in Oman for expatriate individuals. GCC nationals have been granted land ownership rights within the Sultanate that are almost on par with those of Omani nationals. (Among the main distinctions is that non-Omani landowners are required to develop the land and not dispose of it before the lapse of a stipulated time period, and non-Omani landowners face more stringent conditions for minimum build requirements and for assigning their land ownership rights.) Even non-GCC expatriates are now able to own real estate within designated integrated tourism complexes (ITCs) in Oman.

Recently, the Government’s most recent addition to Omani real estate law, Royal Decree No. 43-2012, has taken land ownership rights one step further, by allowing for the “expansion or increase in land area [of a given plot of land]”. The new rule applies to Omanis, GCC nationals, and non-GCC expatriates alike. While this is more of an incremental change compared to some of the sweeping amendments of the past few years, it nevertheless is a promising sign that the Omani authorities are actively focused on reviewing and enhancing the legal framework for real estate ownership in the Sultanate.

Read More...



Tuesday, July 3, 2012

Islamic Banking: A Brief Introduction

The Sultanate of Oman is in the process of establishing the legal and regulatory framework that will be applicable to Islamic banks and to the Islamic “windows” of conventional banks that are licensed to operate in Oman.  Various Islamic banks and windows are being structured and are preparing their initial product offerings.  Over the coming months, the Client Alert will be publishing a series of articles introducing basic Islamic banking concepts, and we will continue to address a range of Islamic finance topics of interest to Omani businesses.

This month, we begin with an introduction to general principles and structures applicable to Islamic banking around the globe.  This introduction is not intended to indicate or imply that any Islamic bank or window licensed in Oman will adopt and apply any specific structure or product discussed in the Client Alert.  Each Islamic bank and window will have a palette of products that is tailored to that bank or window and its clientele.  The particulars of these matters will evolve as the banks and windows are formed and develop, and we will follow these formations and developments for you as they materialize.


Islamic foundations: the Shari`ah supervisory board

Each Islamic bank or window will have a unique Shari`ah supervisory board that will guide that bank or window in designing and implementing its products and conducting its banking activities.  While the relevant policies and regulations have not been finalized as yet, we understand it is proposed that each Islamic bank and window in Oman would be free to determine the composition of its Shari`ah board, subject to some minimal constraints.  Examples of such constraints could include a requirement as to the number of scholars on a Shari`ah board (not less than three is currently being discussed), limitations on the number of boards on which an individual scholar may sit (no more than two boards in the Sultanate), and a requirement that boards include Omani Shari`ah scholars as well as internationally recognized scholars.  At present, it does not appear that there would be a requirement for the scholars to be from specifically identified madhahib (schools of Islamic jurisprudence); the individual banks and windows would be accorded discretion to comprise their Shari`ah boards as they determine appropriate and prudent.  We also understand that there will be no central Shari`ah board at the governmental level (such as a Shari`ah board at the Central Bank of Oman).  The Sultanate will likely take the position that allowing the banks and windows relatively unfettered freedom and discretion in this regard generates greater creativity and responsiveness to market needs and desires.


The function of Islamic banks

Islamic banks and windows perform much the same intermediation functions in the banking system as conventional banks.  They provide (a) asset transformation activities, (b) administration of payments systems, (c) brokerage services, and (d) risk transformation services.  Asset transformation involves the matching the supply of, and the demand for, financial assets and liabilities (e.g., deposits, equity, credit, loans, insurance).  Transformative activities relate to modifications in the scale, maturity and location of instruments and assets.  Payments administration involves, primarily, check transfer activities, electronics funds transfers, settlement activities and clearing activities.  Brokerage activities relate to linking sellers and purchasers of instruments to each other.  Risk transformation pertains to facilitating the supply of, and demand for, intangible and contingent assets and liabilities, including guarantees, collateral, financial advice and custodial services.


The three Islamic banking models
As a theoretical matter, there are three Islamic banking models.  They are commonly referred to as (a) the two-tier mudaraba (service partnership) model, (b) the two windows model, and (c) the wakala (agency) model.  Any given Islamic bank or window may utilize elements of more than one of these models.
Before considering these three models, it is conceptually important to recognize that there are two different types of deposit accounts in the Islamic banking models.  These accounts are the sources of funds for Islamic banks and windows.  Money deposited with a bank by a depositor may go into a demand deposit account or it may go into an investment account.

Generally speaking, there are two types of demand deposits:  savings deposits and current deposits.  In a savings deposit, the depositor may deposit and withdraw money at will, and some banks require minimum deposits.  Structures used for savings deposits include qard hassan (non-interest-bearing loan), wadi`ayaddhamanah (guaranteed safekeeping), and, somewhat infrequently, mudaraba.  In a current deposit, money can be deposited and withdrawn at any time and the account is accompanied by a checking capability or a multifunctional card.  Structures used for current deposits include qard hassan, wadi`ayaddhamanah, and, somewhat infrequently, mudaraba.  Generally, demand deposit accounts do not earn returns (unless a mudaraba structure is used).

Funds that go into investment accounts are invested, with the investments being managed or directed by the bank.  The depositor may lose its deposit in the investment account and, as discussed below, the bank may not guarantee any return of the principal amount of the deposit or on the deposit.  Generally speaking, there are two types of investment accounts: term deposits; and investment deposits.  In a term deposit, money is deposited for a specified minimum period or term and may be withdrawn only at the end of the term.  The maturities used for these accounts are frequently one month to a few years.  The structures used for term accounts include mudaraba and wakala.  An investment deposit is usually a profit and loss sharing account.  Structures used for investment deposits include mudaraba and wakala.

The terms “deposit”, “deposit account”, “depositor” and similar terms are used in this Client Alert because of their familiarity in connection with conventional banking practices.  However, under Islamic banking principles these are not deposits as conventionally conceived.  In many instances they are more in the nature of capital contributions (in the case of monies placed in investment accounts) or loans or safekeeping deposits (in the case of demand deposits).  Returns of and on investment deposits and returns on demand deposits cannot be assured under relevant Shari`ah principles, including by way of deposit insurance as conventionally conceived in most bank regulatory systems.  We understand that the Central Bank of Oman will require Islamic banks and windows to make premium payments to the central deposit insurance program and will require that “depositors” into Islamic banks and windows be afforded deposit insurance protections equivalent to those afforded to depositors in conventional banks.  It is not yet clear how Shari`ah-compliant depositors will be treated in respect of this deposit insurance.  Possibly they will be permitted to decline any deposit insurance payments that may be tendered to them (such a resolution was effected in the United Kingdom).  We will consider this matter in a future Client Alert and/or blog posting.


Islamic banking model #1: Two-tier mudaraba
We begin our discussion of the core Islamic banking models by focusing on the two-tier mudaraba model and investment deposits.  This requires, as background, a brief introduction to the mudaraba contract because that contract is used on both sides of the bank's balance sheet and integrates assets and liabilities.  The first-tier mudaraba contract is between the investor or funds provider (the depositor) and the bank.  The mudaraba agreement provides for a sharing of profits on investment of those deposited funds as between the depositor and the bank.  The second-tier mudaraba contract is between the bank, as investor or funds provider, and third-party entrepreneurs who are seeking funds and agree to share profits with the bank according to the percentages stipulated in the second-tier mudaraba contract.  In the two-tier mudaraba model, both the mobilization of funds (first-tier mudaraba) and the utilization of funds (second-tier mudaraba) are conducted on the basis of profit and loss sharing.
A mudaraba contract structures and defines a type of partnership arrangement in which (i) one or more persons (the “rabbul-mal”) contribute money (or other capital) and (ii) the other person (the “mudarib”) provides services, such as investment of the money provided by the rabbul-mal.  In the banking context, each “depositor” that places funds as an investment deposit is a rabbul-mal.  The mudarib is the bank that manages the investment of those deposited funds.  Those funds are held in trust by the mudarib for the benefit of the depositor rabbul-mal and the bank must use its best efforts to accomplish the objectives of the mudaraba contract.  Frequently, in Islamic banking, there are relatively few restrictions on how the bank may invest those funds.
A defining characteristic of the mudaraba is that losses from the operation of the mudaraba must be borne by the depositor (rabbul-mal) absent misconduct, default or breach of contract by, or negligence of, the mudarib.  The mudarib suffers the loss of its services, and therefore no loss of capital.
Allocation of profits to the bank and the depositor is specified in the mudaraba contract, usually in terms of ratios or percentage allocations or on the basis of a points system that takes cognizance of the amount of the deposit and the time for which the deposit is maintained.  As the investment of a depositor’s funds is usually effected jointly with funds from all depositors, these allocations take into consideration the respective amounts and timing of all investment deposits by all depositors. Profits earned by the depositors are often calculated as a percentage of total banking profits.
A generic two-tier mudaraba model is illustrated in Figure 1.  At the first tier (between the investor (depositor) and the bank), the investors enter into a mudaraba contract with the bank to share profits accruing on the investment account in accordance with defined ratios, percentages or formulas.  It is impermissible to guarantee a return to the depositor. The investors then deposit (or contribute) their funds in investment accounts.  The liability and equity side of the bank’s balance sheet shows the deposits or contributions accepted on a mudaraba basis. These are not liabilities (the capital is not guaranteed).

They are a form of limited-term, non-voting equity.
At the second-tier, the mudaraba contract is between the bank (as the funds supplier and rabbul-mal) and entrepreneurs (mudarib), who share the profits from investment operations according to the terms of this contract and in accordance with specified ratios, allocations or formulas.  Again, guaranteed returns to the rabbul-mal (the bank) are impermissible.
It is apparent from the foregoing description that the asset and liability sides of the bank's balance sheet are fully integrated, thereby minimizing the need for asset liability management, which, in turn, provides stability against economic shocks.
The two-tier mudaraba model has no reserve requirements for the investment accounts because these are profit and loss sharing accounts.  Demand deposits may be accepted in the two-tier mudaraba model.  These deposits provide no returns and are repayable to the depositor on demand, at par.  Thus, they are treated as liabilities of the bank, but frequently have no specific reserve requirements.



Islamic banking model #2: Two windows
The two windows model utilizes both demand deposits and investment deposits. The model divides the liability side of the bank’s balance sheet into (a) a demand deposits window and (b) an investment balances window.  The choices regarding allocation of a depositor’s funds into each of the two windows are left to the depositor.  The demand deposits yield no returns as the deposit is returnable on demand, at par.  These amounts are treated as liabilities.  The bank may earn a service fee for safekeeping services rendered by the bank in connection with the demand deposits.
As a regulatory matter, and quite differently from the two-tier mudaraba model, the reserves applicable to the demand deposits will be 100%.  This is because the funds are treated as amanah safekeeping deposits and do not bear the right of the bank to use the funds to generate further profits on a fractional reserve basis.  The reserve requirement applicable to the investment deposits will be 0% as these amounts are to be invested, are subject to losses, and may not be guaranteed.

Islamic banking model #3: Wakala (agency)
Shari`a Standard No. (23) Agency (“Standard 23”) of the Accounting and Auditing Organization for Islamic Financial Institutions (“AAOIFI”), § 2/1, defines wakala as "the act of one party delegating the other to act on its behalf in what can be a subject matter of delegation“.
In the wakala or agency model, the bank acts as an agent or wakeel for and on behalf of the investor-depositors and investment deposits on a fixed fee basis. A generic wakala-based deposit and investment model is graphically depicted in Figure 2.  The bank generally has broad discretion as to how to invest the deposited funds (so long as the investments are Shari`ah compliant) and notifies the depositor of the profits and losses.  Frequently, the bank will retain profits in excess of a specified rate of return as an incentive fee.  The depositor, as principal (muwakkeel), is responsible for all risks associated with the transaction except for those relating to the agent’s misconduct, fraud, breach, default or negligence.  Guarantees of the deposit are generally impermissible.  The terms of the contract are determined by mutual agreement.
On the liabilities and equity side of the bank’s balance sheet, the bank's relationship with the investor-depositors might be based on a mudaraba, amanah, wakala or wadi`a.  On the assets side of the bank’s balance sheet, the bank has more choices and freedom to invest the depositor’s investments.  There is a broad range of asset investment possibilities, including mudaraba, ijara (lease), istisna` (construction or manufacture financing), murabaha (cost-plus sale), salam (forward sale), and musharaka (partnership).
A wakala is a non-binding contract.  The principal or the agent may withdraw at any time by (a) mutual agreement, (b) unilateral termination, (c) discharging of the obligation, (d) destruction of the subject matter, or (e) death or loss of legal capacity of the contracting parties.  There are some exceptions to the non-binding nature of the contract.  The contract may become binding where (i) the agent is paid, (ii) the rights of third parties are implicated or involved, (iii) the agent starts a task that cannot be stopped without causing damage or injury to the agent or the principal, or (iv) either the principal or the agent promises not to revoke the contract for a specified period.
Agency arrangements can be general and comprehensive or specific and restricted (although the Ḥanafīs and Mālikī, as a classical matter, have ruled general wakala arrangements invalid as they may lead to excessive uncertainty (gharar)).  The agent can be paid or unpaid.  Where the agent is paid, the rules of ijara (for services) are applicable.

Demand Deposits: Qard Hassan and Wadi`a
The qard hassan structure applicable to savings and current account deposits builds upon the concepts set forth in AAOIFI Shari`a Standard No. (19), Loan (Qard) (“Standard 19”).  That standard defines a qard as the transfer of ownership in fungible wealth to a person upon whom it is binding to return wealth similar to it.  The aim of the qard hassan structure is to provide depositors with guaranteed safekeeping of deposits and to allow banks to use the deposits for its banking and business activities.
The deposited amount is treated as a benevolent loan.  The bank is entitled to use the deposited funds without authorization from the depositor.  The bank has an obligation to repay the principal amount of the loan and the principal amount of the loan is guaranteed.  No dividends or returns are due in respect of the deposits.  However, the bank is permitted, in its discretion, to provide, as a gift (hibah) to the depositors, a return on the deposits, although that gift may not be pre-agreed in the deposit contract.
Wadi`a-based deposit structures are also used for savings and current deposits.  A wadi`a (or ida - deposit) is a deposit for safekeeping.  The deposited property must be owned and deliverable and a form of property that can be possessed physically.

There are two general types of wadi`a arrangements: wadi`ayadamanah and wadi`ayaddhamanah.  Wadi`ayadamanah refers to safe custody based on trust.  The custodian must treat the property with the same degree of care as if it were his or her own property and has a duty to protect the property from being lost or damaged.  The custodian is not responsible for damage to the property unless it is due to misconduct, fraud, breach, default or negligence.  The custodian is not entitled to profits gained from the contract and any benefits that accrue from the deposit belong to the owner.  Anything other than safekeeping of the property (e.g., hiring or lending of the deposited property) requires the permission of the owner.  The custodian must return the deposited property to the owners upon the depositor’s request.
Wadi`ayaddhamanah is the more common type of wadi`a in Islamic banking circumstances.  It involves guaranteed safe custody in which the custodian guarantees the return of the property.  It is a combination of two contracts: wadi`a, or safekeeping, and dhaman, or guarantee.  This arrangement may arise if the custodian uses the property for business purposes, destroys the property, or mixes the property with other property in a manner in which the original property cannot be differentiated.  The custodian is entitled to use the deposited property for trading or other business purposes.  The custodian has a right to income derived from the utilization of the deposited property and, at the same time, is liable for any damage or loss to the disk deposited property.  The custodian owns the profit and therefore has no obligation to give a portion of the profit on the property to the depositor, but may do so as a matter of gift (hiba) so long as that is not pre-agreed.  The gift concept, in both forms of wadi`a, is controversial among Shari`ah scholars.  The custodian must return the deposited property to the owners at upon the request of the depositor.

Future articles
Future Client Alert articles will address various types of retail and wholesale products used by Islamic banks and windows and various types of financing and investment products used in the Islamic finance and investment industry.
As the Sultanate of Oman prepares to roll out its new legal and regulatory framework for Islamic banking in the coming months, we will be covering Islamic banking in the Client Alert to educate readers on this important and growing field.  This article is the first in a series by Curtis partner Michael J.T. McMillen, an Islamic finance specialist based in our New York office who provides support to our Islamic banking practice in Oman and throughout the Middle East region.

Read More...



Monday, June 4, 2012

Material Adverse Change Clauses

Material adverse change (“MAC”) clauses (or material adverse effect clauses, as they are also known) are provisions often found in loan and other financing documents which allow lenders to refuse to fund or continue funding a transaction if such a change occurs.

The purpose of the MAC clause is to provide the lender with protection such that if a major adverse change occurs from the date a loan or other financing agreement is signed – and such a change may relate to any number of factors (see below) – then an event of default is triggered and the lender can essentially pull out of the transaction and often demand immediate repayment of any funds already lent to the borrower, together with interest and any other costs payable.

What do MAC clauses cover?

The definition of MAC clauses and their use in documents vary widely, depending on the type of transaction, the market standards at the time of negotiation, the bargaining powers of the parties and a number of external factors including political stability and the economy itself. It is common to see a more aggressive use of MAC clauses from lenders when there is a downturn in the economy and therefore borrowers are forced to accept terms that they would otherwise refuse.

In facility agreements, for example, it is common to see a MAC clause in relation to the following types of changes, among others:

  • • the business, operations, property and financial condition of the borrower;
  • • the borrower’s or the borrower group’s ability to perform its obligations under the finance documents;
  • • the validity, effectiveness, enforceability or ranking of any security granted under the finance documents; and
  • • the international financial markets.
This means that if a material adverse change occurs in relation to any of the above – this determination is often made at the lender’s sole discretion – then an event of default is triggered and the lender can stop the financing and demand repayment of all borrowings and costs to date.

How are MAC clauses defined?

The definition of the MAC clause is one of the most important and heavily negotiated definitions in any finance documentation.

Lenders typically seek to keep the definition as wide as possible and may require that an event of default is triggered if an event has a material adverse effect on the borrower’s ability to perform any of its obligations under the finance documents. Conversely, borrowers seek to keep the definition as narrow as possible and will seek to agree that an event of default is only triggered if a material adverse change affects its ability to comply with its financial covenants or payment obligations under the finance documents.

While many of the negotiations surrounding finance documents often seem more theoretical, or point-scoring, than practically applicable, the MAC clause is, in fact, a clause which can and is invoked. Most recently, we have seen two cases in Oman where Omani banks have invoked the clause, causing the relevant borrowers to have to refinance their loans as a result.

Where a lender has successfully negotiated that it will determine the occurrence of a material adverse change “in its sole discretion”, it is usual for borrowers to negotiate that the lender “act reasonably”. Borrowers also seek to negotiate materiality qualifications, i.e., that if a material adverse change has occurred that it will have a material effect on a material obligation. This is to avoid an event of default being triggered over a trivial breach or the breach of a trivial term.

Read More...



Tuesday, May 22, 2012

Labor Law Update: New Ministerial Decision Requires Private-Sector Salary Increases

In a development of importance to private-sector employers and employees throughout the Sultanate, the Ministry of Manpower has recently issued Ministerial Decision No. 32/2012, which mandates annual salary increases for private-sector workers in Oman. MD No. 32/2012, which applies to all employees in the private-sector and became effective on 30 January 2012, entitles employees to a salary increase of at least 3% each year.

MD No. 32/2012 provides that, each year, every employee who has been working for his employer for at least six months as of January 1st of such year shall be entitled to receive an annual increase to his basic salary for such year equal to at least 3% of his previous year’s basic salary, with effect from January 1st of such year. However, employees who have been rated as underperforming in their annual appraisal for the previous year may not be eligible to receive such an annual salary increase for the new year. Please note that MD No. 32/2012 sets 3% as the minimum threshold for an employee’s annual salary increase, and is without prejudice to any terms more favourable to the employee stated in his employment contract.

Read More...



Thursday, May 17, 2012

Franchise Agreements

The Sultanate of Oman features an array of international goods and services providers, many of which are operated as franchises. Eateries such as McDonald’s and Starbucks, retailers such as H&M and Zara are just a few examples of Oman’s thriving franchise sector. Such franchises represent not only an important segment of the Sultanate’s existing commercial landscape, but also a significant opportunity for Omani entrepreneurs to start new businesses.

This article provides an overview of what franchises are and discusses key legal and commercial issues relevant to entrepreneurs looking to start a franchise in Oman, particularly with US franchisors.

What is a Franchise?

Although the word “franchise” often conjures images of particular kinds of businesses – such as fast food restaurants or budget hotel chains – franchising is actually used across a broad spectrum of enterprises. What all franchises have in common are (i) a branded line of products and/or services, (ii) an operating system prescribed by the franchisor, and (iii) one or more fees charged to franchisees for the right to participate in the business system by selling the branded products and/or services and by utilizing the franchisor’s operating system. Franchisors and franchisees are independent business entities, and franchisors typically derive their income from initial and ongoing fees paid by their franchisees. Sometimes franchisors also sell items to franchisees or collect fees from franchisees’ suppliers.

For example, in the case of a fast food restaurant such as McDonald’s, the franchisor, McDonald’s Incorporated, has created and maintains (i) a brand together with intellectual property (e.g., the golden arches logo) and products (e.g., the Big Mac hamburger) associated with the brand, and (ii) a system for operating McDonald’s restaurants, which likely includes detailed guidelines for restaurant layout and decoration, food preparation guidelines, customer service guidelines, and many other requirements. McDonald’s franchisees, namely the businessmen and companies that own and operate McDonald’s restaurants throughout the world, pay franchise fees to McDonald’s Incorporated in exchange for the right to use McDonald’s Incorporated’s brand and operating system.

The legal framework for franchising in Oman

In some jurisdictions, there is a separate legal framework that governs franchises. However, in Oman franchises are simply considered another form of commercial agency. Accordingly, franchise agreements, like any agency or distribution agreement, are governed by Oman’s Commercial Agency Law, unless the agreement is expressed to be governed by the laws of a country other than Oman, coupled with an arbitration clause.

To form a legally valid franchise relationship in Oman, it is necessary for the franchisor and franchisee to enter into a franchise agreement and to register in the Commercial Agents Registry at the Ministry of Commerce & Industry.

The franchise agreement is naturally a very important document to the franchisor and the franchisee alike. Although the franchise agreement will usually be based on the franchisor’s standard form, it is important for the franchisee (and, we recommend, the franchisees legal advisors) to review the franchise agreement carefully and negotiate its key points with the franchisor. From the perspective of an Omani franchisee, the key issues are likely to be:

  • the fees that the franchisee will be obliged to pay to the franchisor;
  • the services that the franchisor will provide to the franchisee (for example, training and marketing support);
  • the scope of the franchise rights (for example, geographical reach);
  • the reasonableness and attainability of any performance targets or restrictions that the franchisor may impose on the franchisee;
  • whether the franchisee is being appointed on an exclusive or non-exclusive basis; and
  • the governing law and jurisdiction clause.
Franchise Disclosure Documents (FDDs)

Every prospective franchisee would do well to obtain detailed information about the franchisors that interest him. Fortunately, when it comes to US franchisors, this information is fairly easy to come by.

US franchisors are required to deliver Franchise Disclosure Documents (FDDs) to prospective franchisees for locations within the US, although this requirement does not apply abroad. Franchise laws in twenty other countries also require franchisors to prepare FDDs. FDDs contain invaluable information about the experience of the franchisors and their executives, including the number of units of the franchise opened and closed in recent years, litigation and bankruptcy history, initial investment estimates, audited financial statements of the franchisor, and contact information for the franchisor’s current franchisees, as well as those who have left the brand during the franchisor’s last fiscal year.

Every prospective franchisee should study the information required to be included in the FDD, however US franchisors are often advised by their lawyers not to provide the FDD to foreign franchisee prospects because international franchise agreements usually differ from the US domestic agreements, and the laws of most countries, such as Oman, do not require them to make such detailed disclosures. Franchisors may also fear that if they have no experience in operating businesses in a new market, such as Oman, that a US-oriented FDD could mislead prospective Omani franchisees. Nevertheless, we strongly recommend that an Omani franchisee should demand and examine the franchisor’s FDDs prepared for the US market, as these documents will contain useful information that the prospective franchisee can use in evaluating specific franchise opportunities.

Other recommendations

In order to take advantage of the best available franchising opportunities and to avoid problems with inexperienced or undercapitalized franchisors, prospective Omani franchisees should consider the following:

  • Only acquire a franchise if you are comfortable with the franchisor, the people who lead it, and its organizational culture.
  • Obtain an FDD of the franchisor, even if it is prepared for the US market. Many FDDs are available online. Many franchisors prepare international or country-specific FDDs and will normally provide them to prospective franchisees without their having to ask.
  • Contact unit franchisees in the US and elsewhere. Many franchisees are willing to share information about their experiences with prospective franchisees.
  • Although franchisor executives describe franchising as a relationship which is a form of partnership, franchise agreements are complex documents which define the relationship and carefully define the rights, duties and remedies of franchisees. A lawyer with a sophisticated understanding of international franchising can help you to understand, evaluate and negotiate a franchise agreement.
  • Be wary of a franchisor that is willing to make substantial modifications to its franchise program for the sake of concluding a deal. Franchisors should have a business plan for your market, and should demand that you present them with a business plan of your own before reaching agreement on a franchise relationship.
  • Check out other resources at http://www.franchise.org/ and also check with the US Foreign and Commercial Services at the US Embassy in Muscat for information about evaluating US franchisors offering franchises in Oman.

Read More...



Thursday, May 10, 2012

Taking Security: Commercial Mortgages

In Part I of this article, which was featured in a previous post, we provided an overview of what commercial mortgages are and the fundamental legal concepts that govern them in Oman. This month we conclude by discussing further the registration requirements for commercial mortgages, along with potential enforcement issues.

 Further details on commercial mortgage registration

For a commercial mortgage to remain valid, its registration must be renewed every five years at the Ministry of Commerce & Industry (MCI). A commercial mortgage can be released and removed from the register of the MCI by the expiry of the mortgage after five years, i.e., without its renewal. It can also be released and removed by virtue of a court order or written agreement of the borrower and the lender.

Details of the commercial mortgage are set out in the commercial registration papers of the borrower. These details include the name of the mortgagee, the date of the charge and the assets mortgaged. In practice, the MCI require the consent of the lender to make any changes to the commercial registration of the borrower once the commercial mortgage has been registered even if only one asset, such as a rig, has been mortgaged.

The registration of a commercial mortgage at the MCI requires the assets to be located in Oman and the borrower to be incorporated in Oman. For moveable property such as ships and aircraft, the vessel must be registered in Oman as the mortgage will be registered against the title to the ship or, as the case may be, the aircraft. Such registrations will be with the relevant authority and not with the MCI.

Potential enforceability issues

If the borrower fails to pay its debt, then a court order is required by the lender to enforce the commercial mortgage against the assets of the borrower (unless the borrower otherwise cooperates with the lender’s enforcement against its assets). This can be a long process and it can take up to two years to obtain the court order. The assets will then be sold by public auction administered by the Omani courts and the lender only will be entitled to the proceeds of sale of the asset sufficient to discharge the secured loan. It is not possible for a lender to simply take physical possession of any secured assets and sell them without the involvement of the Omani courts.

In practice, in relation to limited recourse projects and other transactions, commercial mortgages have been granted and registered by the MCI over a wide range of contracts and government licences. But in our view, there is serious doubt about the ability to mortgage and enforce a mortgage over contracts and government licences. The fact that such commercial mortgages have been registered by the MCI does not mean that they will automatically be enforceable in the Omani courts. In relation to contracts, many of the borrower’s rights under contracts are contingent or come into effect in the future. In addition, many contracts, by their very terms, are not capable of being sold in the manner that mortgaged assets are sold by the Omani courts on enforcement, and consent of the counterparty to any transfer of obligations is likely to be required. In a similar manner, most government licences are not capable of being sold and as a matter of law are generally personal to the borrower.

Read More...